Most of my photos taken for the past 7 months (started 1 month after buying the DSLR camera)
Reading from the Photography magazine, Photoplus and Digital Camera, all the professional photographers have always recommended to shoot in raw.
I set WB in AWB mode because a lot of time it gives correct setting. The two images below were taken a few minute apart with the same setting but they came out with different colour.
Currently I am using Photoshop CS to process my raw and jpeg but I was advised by the tutor and some of my more experienced photographer friends that I should use "Light room" to process raw images. I might have to look into it. (but not yet)
I chose 3 images from the library I took not so long ago. They were shot in 3 different lighting. I didn't plan and shoot three new images because I only want to compare the quality between the images.
1) Day light
The image below could be considered as HDR too but the image was taken on a sunny day. I meter at the sky because I love how the cloud is formed so the foreground is a bit dark. I don't have ND grad filter at the moment.

JPEG - this image has no adjustment. I could adjust the lighting using curves / level but I am not really good at it (just yet). I have noticed though that the histogram has broken after applying the adjustment.

adjusted from RAW version 1
adjusted WB only

adjusted from RAW version 2 adjusted WB and curve too. However the histogram for these 2 jpegs adjusted from RAW are not broken that means no detail has lost.
The shadow is still there (in the tree shade) that I can't reproduce detail.
I think next time I will have to either, take 2 pictures and merge exposure or use ND grad filter.
2) Artificial lighting

This was taken inside an exhibition hall. The light was mixed between tungsten and day light.Using Adobe Bridge viewing raw and jpeg, I can tell the different between the colour of image. The raw image, which contain complete data, has less colour cast, less orange which I prefer.
The histogram charts for both jpeg and raw are similar but not exactly the same. Raw image shows the shadow and highlight while the jpeg doesn't.
3) High dynamic range
jpeg
rawThese images were taken on a sunny day too so they could be considered "day light"
Using Adobe Bridge to view the RAW and JPEG images, I could easily see the different of colour between raw and jpeg. I prefer the raw one because the sky has deeper blue colour.
Conclusion:
From all 3 different images (RAW and JPEG)
1. RAW contains all data which means when the raw image is adjusted using computer software, no data is lost while JPEG has been processed in camera therefore some data has been lost forever and during post-processing in computer software each time, more data is lost again. so the quality of Jpeg will be reduced.
2. viewing RAW image in the computer software can show highlight and shadow clipping while Jpeg can not.
3. RAW has (my) preferred colour whilte JPEG often looks fake. (but sometimes jpeg looks OK.
4. JPEG is easier and quicker to record and share while RAW has be to be processed before it can be uploaded and shared which is more time consuming.
For me: I will still continue shooting RAW and JPEG so that if need be, I can just use JPEG very quickly. But if time permitted, I will process RAW and turn to JPEG before sharing.
No comments:
Post a Comment